ICL and LASIK both correct nearsightedness, and the 2023 study found comparable overall visual outcomes, though the studies below also found differences in halos, far-distance acuity and signal-to-noise ratio. In a 2023 PubMed study on SMILE, FS-LASIK and ICL of 131 eyes, the three procedures had comparable visual outcomes, and the one clear difference was halos, which ICL patients reported more often. Which one suits you depends on your prescription, your corneas and your eye health, and an eye surgeon makes that call after an exam.
One published study is a 2019 PubMed study on Toric ICL and SMILE. It analyzed FDA summary safety and effectiveness data for Toric ICL, SMILE and topography-guided LASIK. In eyes with prescriptions stronger than 10 diopters, 66% of Toric ICL eyes landed within half a diopter (±0.50 D) of the intended correction, compared with 100% of SMILE eyes. The authors wrote that SMILE may be comparable to Toric ICL for high myopia or myopic astigmatism.
What is not known yet is whether those results hold for your prescription, and how long they last.

Is ICL good for your eyes?
As of October 2026, the research points to good visual results with ICL, with a few trade-offs. Three findings matter most.
- The 2019 study concluded that all three methods it analyzed had “excellent efficacy, safety, stability, and accuracy.”
- 2025 PubMed study on ICL V4c and FS-LASIK followed 58 patients (116 eyes) for an average of about 55 months. Both procedures gave long-term safety and efficacy for binocular vision, and ICL and FS-LASIK were done without complications in all subjects. A difference in far-distance visual acuity was also observed (0.05 with ICL V4c, 0.10 with FS-LASIK, P = 0.02). The signal-to-noise ratio, an objective measure of visual quality, was lower with ICL (5.41 vs 8.00 with FS-LASIK, P < 0.001).
- Sweeney Eye Associates, which offers EVO ICL, says nearly 95% of individuals reached 20/40 or better without glasses three years after surgery, and reports a 99% satisfaction rate. Another section of its page gives more than 99% for the same 20/40 measure, so ask the surgeon for the figure in writing.
How successful are LASIK and ICL?
Studies measure success in different ways, so compare the measures, not one headline percentage. In the 2023 study, SMILE, FS-LASIK and ICL had safety indices of 1.21, 1.22 and 1.22, and efficacy indices of 1.18, 1.15 and 1.17. Overall visual quality did not differ significantly between the three. Sweeney reports that 98.5% of individuals see the same or better than with glasses or contacts within six months. Ask your surgeon which study that figure comes from.
Is there a difference between laser and LASIK?
Yes. LASIK stands for laser in situ keratomileusis, and it is one type of laser eye surgery. FS-LASIK is a femtosecond laser-assisted version, and TG-LASIK is topography-guided. ICL is a different kind of procedure: a lens placed inside the eye. Sweeney describes EVO ICL as correcting vision “without the need to alter the cornea.” The studies above also compare these with SMILE and PRK.
A 2020 PubMed study on LASIK, PRK and ICL of 654 eyes found that the final prescription tracked distance vision most closely for FS-LASIK and LASIK, and less closely for PRK and PRK Xtra. The table compares what each study or practice page says.
| Option | What the research or practice says | Who it may suit | Limits named |
|---|---|---|---|
| LASIK (FS-LASIK, TG-LASIK) | 2019: TG-LASIK showed no further gain in uncorrected distance vision from 3 to 12 months. 2023: overall comparable to ICL and SMILE. | Patients whose exam shows a suitable cornea and prescription | Sweeney gives a range of up to -12.0 D. Specialty Eye Institute lists dry eyes, severe myopia and thin corneas as reasons some people are not candidates. |
| SMILE | 2019: uncorrected distance vision kept improving from 3 to 12 months; more accurate than Toric ICL for cylinder; comparable to Toric ICL for high myopia. 2023: fewer halos than ICL. | Eyes with high myopia or myopic astigmatism, per the 2019 study’s conclusion | The 2019 study says visual recovery may be longer than with TG-LASIK, longer than previously indicated. |
| PRK and PRK Xtra | 2020: final prescription tracked distance vision less closely than with LASIK or FS-LASIK. | Depends on your exam | Ask your surgeon how it compares for your eyes. |
| ICL (Visian and Toric) | 2019: Toric ICL reached ±0.50 D in 66% of eyes above 10 D. 2023: more halos than SMILE or FS-LASIK. 2025: long-term safety and efficacy for ICL V4c. | Specialty Eye Institute describes Visian ICL for ages 21 to 45 who are nearsighted without astigmatism | Sweeney says traditional ICL may need iridotomies, and names cataract and further surgery as concerns. |
| EVO ICL | Sweeney says FDA approval covers ages 21 to 60 from February 2026. It corrects -3.0 to -20.0 D and astigmatism of 1.0 to 4.0 D. | Sweeney: stable nearsightedness or astigmatism, including thin corneas or high prescriptions | Sweeney describes a higher cost and a need for careful patient selection. |
| Eye exercise programs | Harvard Health says their makers have not run randomized trials. Practiced faithfully, they may help delay the need for glasses in some people. | Those who want a non-surgical route alongside their glasses | Will not eliminate nearsightedness, farsightedness, astigmatism or presbyopia, and will not keep you out of glasses if you need them. |
Sweeney Eye Associates offers EVO ICL, so read its comparison as the case for ICL. The published studies give the side-by-side comparison.
EVO ICL vs LASIK: what is the difference?
Sweeney Eye Associates makes these claims for EVO ICL:
- It corrects nearsightedness from -3.0 to -20.0 D, compared with LASIK’s range of up to -12.0 D.
- It works without altering the cornea and “preserves corneal tissue.”
- It takes about 20 minutes per eye under local anesthesia. The practice says it is often favored for a streamlined approach and lower risk of complications.
- It cites a safety index of 1.25, supported by three years of clinical safety data on 629 eyes.
Ask your surgeon to show you the same measures for LASIK before you compare.
What is ICL surgery, and how long does it take?
Specialty Eye Institute describes Visian ICL as a flexible lens placed in the eye, between the iris and the natural lens. It says an ophthalmologist can perform the surgery in around 15 minutes in an outpatient setting, that sutures are typically not needed, and that recovery “may be as little as a day.” Sweeney gives about 20 minutes per eye for EVO ICL, and says traditional ICL can need extra steps such as creating iridotomies. The two practices give different times, so ask your surgeon for theirs.
How much does ICL cost compared with LASIK?
Prices change and vary by surgeon and region, so check today’s price directly with the surgeon’s office. Ask for a written, itemized quote that lists the surgery, the lens if you are getting ICL, follow-up visits and any extra testing. Sweeney describes EVO ICL’s cost as higher, so compare the totals on the same list.
Does LASIK permanently fix your eyes, and what happens after 10 years?
Specialty Eye Institute calls LASIK a permanent surgery and says Visian ICL can be removed or replaced if necessary. Permanent means the change to your eye stays. It does not stop aging. Harvard Health on eye exercises notes that presbyopia, the age-related stiffening of the lens, progresses with time, so near vision can keep changing after any procedure.
The longest follow-up in the studies above, a 2025 study, averages about 55 months, roughly four and a half years. For what happens at 10 years, ask your surgeon for long-term outcome data on the exact procedure you would have. For a regret rate, ask the practice for its own satisfaction and regret figures, and ask how it collected them.
What are the side effects, and what can go wrong?
The 2023 study found that glare, fluctuating vision and halos were the most common visual symptoms three months after surgery, across all three procedures. Patients with larger pupils in dim light had a higher risk of glare. Halos were reported more often after ICL than after SMILE or FS-LASIK.
Sweeney says infection and increased eye pressure are risks to discuss with an ophthalmologist. For the older, traditional ICL, it names cataract formation and the possibility of additional surgeries. It gives a 0.16% rate of anterior subcapsular cataract for EVO ICL and calls that low.
Who may not be a candidate for LASIK or ICL?
Specialty Eye Institute lists dry eyes, severe myopia and thin corneas as reasons some people may not be candidates for LASIK. It describes Visian ICL for people aged 21 to 45 who are nearsighted without astigmatism, have not had an eyeglass prescription change in the last year, and are not pregnant. Sweeney says thin corneas or high prescriptions can make LASIK unsuitable, and describes EVO ICL for stable nearsightedness or astigmatism in people aged 21 to 60.
The Specialty page describes Visian ICL for nearsightedness without astigmatism, while the 2019 study covers the Toric version for myopic astigmatism. Ask which lens version your surgeon would use.
These are the criteria the practices give, not a full checklist. Your eye exam decides which procedure, if any, is right for you.
Is there an age when LASIK or ICL stops being worth it?
Age limits are set for each procedure, and the practices differ. Specialty Eye Institute gives 21 to 45 for Visian ICL. As of October 2026, Sweeney says the FDA’s approval of EVO ICL for ages 21 to 60 took effect in February 2026. For LASIK, ask your surgeon what age range they treat and how they decide at the edges.
Could I do an eye exercise routine myself instead?
Eye exercise programs are promoted as a way to avoid surgery and glasses. Harvard Health says their makers have not run randomized trials to check them, and that exercising eye muscles will not eliminate nearsightedness, farsightedness, astigmatism or presbyopia. Practiced faithfully, eye exercises may help delay the need for glasses in some people, and you do not need to buy a special program to get that. The same source says it is safe to assume such programs will not keep you out of glasses if you need them.
Is LASIK becoming less popular?
Sweeney Eye Associates says laser-based refractive procedures have decreased by nearly 40% over the past three years. That is one practice’s figure, and the practice offers ICL. Check it against national data, and ask your surgeon what they see in their own practice.
Before you decide
- Ask which procedure your surgeon recommends for your prescription and corneas, and why.
- Ask whether your astigmatism is part of the plan, and which lens version you would receive.
- Ask for the long-term outcome data for that exact procedure.
- Ask for an itemized written quote that includes follow-up visits and extra testing.
- Ask for the practice’s satisfaction and regret figures, and where they come from.
Eye surgery is a decision to make with an eye surgeon after an exam. Book a consultation and bring this list.
By SterlingMedicalCenter.org Editorial Team
This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Consult your doctor or qualified healthcare provider before making changes to your health routine.